i think, there is a great deal of ‘confusion’ - caused by low iq ‘interpretation’ of digital id : as in indian - aadhar..
the ‘confusion’ arrives from multiple sources..
lets revisit - ‘past’...of ‘independence’...
we were ‘free’ - but with ‘architecture’ of brits - democraxy.
it was ‘amended’ and adopted - scaled for ‘indian’ culture and principles of it..
no left/right - but multiple - opinions.
so a technically - superior - democracy..
which had to ‘scale’ for 1 B people.
the ‘problem’ : was ‘scale’..
end citizen : connectivity..
which made ‘problems’ of india/indians - a bit less : coz of leadersheep of bureaucracy of iaps muggers and lineages of dem.
so ‘digital id’ or ‘aadhar’ : became ‘solution’ - but with different ‘money’ and system to run it - upi.
the west's perspective : is of ‘control’...
coz - dey never had problems of ‘scale’
...just their indifference - bred from nihilism and hollow - beliefs
their problem : is self created/imported problems...
which are compounded as ‘solution’ for all the illogical of dem.
digital id : is a solution for ‘scale’ of governance..
not a solution for lack of it.
...and the most obvious ground reality of India - ‘cash’ can never go away.
it was the ‘problem’ which gave solution as aadhar.